Flash Corporate Websites are Dead…Oh…and Intros Too

Flash is an awesome technology.  We at xiik use it all the time, in fact.  You’ll notice that about half of our sites have a Flash element somewhere.  Flash components, integrated into a webpage, are great for displaying several pictures in a rotation, showing video or playing audio.  That doesn’t give you a lisence to use it for your whole site.

There was a period of time when Flash first came out that everybody jumped on the bandwagon and decided to (over)use it.  Similar to how frames and blinking text could be found on every site built in 1998, Flash was huge soon thereafter.  Then came the sudden slowdown as people realized incompatability issues – your users had to download a Flash Player to display Flash on your site – and that the load times were really bad for dialup users.  Unfortunately, this only slowed the overabundance of Flash sites briefly, as the newest versions of each browser came with Flash pre-installed and cable modems/DSL became more prevalent.

Fast-forward 8-10 years.  Now Flash is everywhere, again.  The trendiest places, especially restaurants, bars and music venues want to go all-Flash because things move and there are pictures and it’s interactive and it’s just…”wow”.  Somewhere along the way web designers united in giving up function for form.

What’s wrong with Flash sites?  Well, picture yourself at a social event (as I was last Thursday) at 10pm, trying to decide if you are going to walk 3 blocks down the street in negative temperatures to grab food at the hot new restaurant, Forty-Five Degrees.  Unfortunately, you can’t remember if they stop serving at 10 or 11pm.  Never fear – you pull out your trusty iPhone, type in the URL (http://www.fortyfiveindy.com).  To your surprise, you don’t pull up a hot and trendy website but, instead, receive dreaded blue box, indicating that the site is in Flash and cannot be viewed on mobile devices.  The owner of this establishment would not be delighted to know that he has now paid a lot for a site that has not reached his prospective customer – whom I’m sure would think it was lovely if they could actually see it – but, instead, has annoyed said customer to the point of PG-13 language.

Besides being completely unusable on most mobile devices, many find the sites annoying even on PCs.  Most users want to go to a site, find what they are looking for and move on.  This becomes difficult when they have to watch the site animate into a pretty picture, as I did this afternoon while waiting for http://www.scholarsinn.com/ to draw itself, wondering why they decided it was okay to waste my time.  Not to mention the near heart-attack it gave me when the music started playing (but we’ll save that for another blog).

Flash can still be used for portfolio sites, sites for kids or sites that should be interactive.  But if you’re trying to give people information like, say, your hours of operations, DON’T USE FLASH!  Already got a Flash site?  Simple fix – add your phone number, address and hours of operation to the bottom of every page of your website in HTML.  That way, even if they can’t see the pretty site you built for them, you at least won’t lose the customer.

And while the soapbox is still planted firmly beneath my feet, I’d also like to say that Flash intros are a HUGE no-no.  Nobody has the time or desire to wait for an intro to play.  In fact, every client we’ve worked with who requested it admitted that they always click the “Skip” button.  Don’t waste your money.  Spend it on things that the customer will appreciate and use.

Got questions?  Give us a call – 888.900.XIIK or visit us online at http://www.xiik.com

 

UPDATE:  Since the initial posting, 45 Degrees has changed their website from full-Flash to a hybrid (HTML with a really cool Flash component).  I doubt that this blog posting had anything to do with that, nor do I know what the reasons were behind the change.  However, I wanted to make sure that was clear that I was referring to their old site.  Not the new one.

8 Comments

  1. Posted February 21, 2009 at 10:19 pm | Permalink

    Hey Xiik, interesting article. I started to respond on here but ended up wroting so much that it deserved its own post. Please take a minute and check out my response: http://blog.ickydime.com/2009/02/flash-corporate-websites-are-dead-i.html

    I hope it spurs a friendly and educational debate.

    Thanks

  2. Posted February 21, 2009 at 11:41 pm | Permalink

    Just use swfObject for your flash content and use alternative content for people that cant see flash on your site.

    Why should a whole industry accommodate one corporations incompetents? Why not hold the IPhone accountable or your self for buying the IPhone? Get a clue!

    • Posted February 22, 2009 at 6:33 am | Permalink

      Great comment, Josh.

      The whole industry should not accommodate Apple. But it is our responsibility as web developers and marketers to get our client’s message to their consumers. If up to 30% of their mobile consumers use the iPhone (quickly Googling “iPhone share of smartphone market” gives ranges from 16-30%), simply blaming the consumer or “holding them accountable” for buying an iPhone and denying them alternative access doesn’t seem like we’d be doing our clients justice. Most of us are pretty passionate about our iPhones. We’d sooner leave the Flash-based site for a competitor’s than replace our phone. Nobody wins in that scenario.

      I think that your comment regarding the swfObject is a great solution. I only wish that more sites were doing it! I believe I recommended including some non-Flash content on any all-Flash website for those who can’t view Flash. Just as we check for JavaScript and display different content for incapable browsers, we must do the same for our non-Flash-capable users. I, for one, hate building multiple versions of the same site for different types of users, but we accommodated for Netscape, for Safari and even some for Chrome browsers. Now we’re just doing it for mobile devices that can’t see Flash. This isn’t new. Thanks again for your comment.

  3. Hugo M.
    Posted February 23, 2009 at 2:53 pm | Permalink

    Hello all,
    I have my two cents about this as well, you guys are right in every statement you do and yes flash was overused, but not by making a full flash website, just by always using it all the time.
    Where i really want to get is the common problem between brands and agencies, what about the consumer ? did you even try asking the consumer what’s it’s stand in the matter ? does he use flash a lot ? 99% penetration in the market would indicate that, what about the mobile bandwagon. Well i have an iphone ( I hope apple sorts things out with adobe because i really want to get flash player on the iphone ) I’m also a flash developer but most of all I’m a consumer and i like to be able to see flash websites on my desktop or laptop, I don’t get mad if I see a website done in html+javascript and the likes as long as it’s well developed and it doesn’t fail in the content where i need it (content should always be king no matter the medium you choose to display it and the inherent technology used). So my main point of view is let the consumer opt-in, it’s his mobile, it’s his mind, it’s his judgement people should make a website available in the most broad way for a consumer and there are ways to check what is the mobile the consumer is using and redirect him to an appropriate version of the website.

    • qwe
      Posted April 13, 2010 at 8:40 am | Permalink

      how could u say that, flash has being there and will for ever be. Long live FLASH

  4. jsFanboy
    Posted June 5, 2009 at 6:54 pm | Permalink

    I hate Flash. I think more things can and should be accomplished with JavaScript.

  5. Posted March 26, 2010 at 8:45 pm | Permalink

    One simple question before one line of code is typed: “Is Flash necessary?” should do the trick.

    Flash, like any tool, can be dangerous in the wrong hands. Conversely, it can render things of beauty.

    There is nothing wrong with Flash. It cannot build websites by itself. The real criminals here are designers who employ Flash like an old lady spraying cheap perfume.

    And the 45 Degrees site is still annoying.

  6. Sal
    Posted April 15, 2010 at 5:20 pm | Permalink

    ‘Consumer choice’ is anathema to Apple – hopefully the Mac sheep will wake from Big Brother’s slumber and the IPhone will be obsolete before Flash is.


10 Trackbacks

  1. By Is Flash dead? | SHRINKthechurch on December 18, 2009 at 5:15 pm

    [...] But in 2010, all that has changed. Almost all computers connected to the internet are running the most recent Flash update and the average internet speed can handle almost anything a Flash application could offer without taking away from the user experience. So why are fully Flash sites disappearing? [...]

  2. [...] [...]

  3. By The Gradual Disappearance Of Flash Websites on April 12, 2010 at 9:45 am

    [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  4. [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  5. [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  6. [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  7. [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  8. [...] [...]

  9. [...] Flash Corporate Websites Are Dead… Oh, and Intros, Too, by Xiik [...]

  10. [...] are particularly important to xiik — we have discussed and detailed our stance about it in a previous blog post. If you notice the comments below that article, it is obvious this is a heated topic of debate — [...]

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.